This thesis draws on david harveys concept of accumulation by dispossession and an international political economy ipe approach centred on the institutional arrangements and power structures that privilege certain actors and values, in. The terms dispossession and expropriation nevertheless persist in some forms by thinkers of a more marxian orientation even to the present, most obviously in david harveys claim that accumulation by dispossession best characterizes a neoliberal era of capitalism. I therefore determined to try as best i could to penetrate beneath the surface flux to divine some of the deeper currents in the making of the. Umbc geography and environmental systems department. The politics of dispossession economic sociology and. Since the beginning of capitalism in land has been a major asset of production and. This thesis draws on david harveys concept of accumulation by dispossession and an international political economy ipe approach centred on the institutional arrangements and power structures that privilege certain actors and values. Accumulation by dispossession download download pdf. In a speech to the knesset, netanyahu quoted rabin, saying that. From primitive accumulation to regimes of dispossession. However, many scholars have argued that the idea of a generic global land grab conceals a wide variety of more. Accumulation by dispossession by the global extractive. A combination of trends has contributed to the current twentyfirstcentury wave of land grabs. It defines neoliberal capitalist policies that result in a centralization of wealth and power in the hands of a few by dispossessing the public and private entities of their wealth or land.
From incremental dispossession to a cumulative land grab. Slums, slumdogs, and accumulation by dispossession tayyab mahmud marooned on the outskirts of the law, more than one billion people worldwide live in urban slums and squatter settlements, mostly in the global south. By freeing marxs primitive accumulation from its narrow role in the transition between modes of production, harvey has created. This phenomenon has led to an unequal repartition of property rights allowing capitalist accumulation through the dispossession of local communities harvey, 2003. Accumulation by dispossession cannot be dissociated from the pivotal role of imperialism and colonialism in the process of capitalist development. Taking structural violence and accumulation by dispossession as lenses through which to deploy counternarratives expounding on the inherent violence of statebacked capitalist accumulation, discourses of fear and othering can be replaced by imaginaries of resistance and hope springer, 2011. For harvey, this form of accumulation has proved persistent throughout history. The thesis examines how accumulation by dispossession by the global extractive industry is facilitated by the free entry or free mining principle. Consider, for example, marxs argument concerning the creation of an industrial reserve army. Accumulation by dispossession by the global extractive industry. Pdf the accumulation of dispossession and resistance in. Overaccumulated capital can seize hold of such assets and immediately turn them to pro. What accumulation by dispossession does is release a set of assets including labourpower at very low and in some instances zero cost.
In this blogpost daniel bin argues that africa is probably the most significant area of socalled land grabs, one example of dispossession. Whereas marx labeledtheseprimitiveformsofaccumulation, harvey insists that they are omnipres. However, radical political economy must be clearer about what we mean since most discussion of dispossession neglects a consideration of actual capitalist accumulation. Danish khan october 2019 4 i received distinction in ph. The motivations and the ways by which dispossession is carried out have shifted as the actors who extract rents, the mechanisms by which rents are extracted from housing, and the goals of post. The role of regulations in the spanish housing dispossession. Women from honduras and guatemala in the global scramble for land paper prepared for presentation at the 2016 world bank conference on land and poverty the world bank washington dc, march 1418, 2016 trocaire wp report dd 2 09032016 3. The great social housing swindle p aul sngs documentary offers a carefully balanced, clearheaded study of the myriad ways the uk property market has skewed and malfunctioned in.
Accumulation by dispossession of capitalism forcing it to seek solutions external to itself. The accumulation of dispossession and resistance in northern uganda conference paper pdf available october 2012 with 142 reads how we measure reads. Harvey himself argues that accumulation by dispossession can be seen as the necessary cost of making a successful breakthrough to capitalist and socialist development, but he also argues that in some instances particularly post1973 accumulation by dispossession, rather than opening up a new path of expanded reproduction, disrupted and. For example, from luxemburg comes a sense of primitive accumulation as a permanent mode of imperial accumulation by dispossession in david harveys terms such that. Jharkhands history of coal mining stretches back over a century when peasants and landowners turned to coal for windfall gains rothermund and wadhwa, 1978 and in the process transformed the land into a continuous urban. Situating the promises of big data within the utopian imaginaries of digital frontierism, we suggest processes of data colonialism are actually. Harvey himself argues that accumulation by dispossession can be seen as the necessary cost of making a successful breakthrough to capitalist and socialist development, but he also argues that in some instances particularly post1973 accumulation by dispossession, rather than opening up a new path of expanded reproduction, disrupted and destroyed paths that were already open ibid 154. Although each of these conflicts produced a violent dispossession process, none of them resembled the rural dispossession process in england. Pdf drawing upon the concept of accumulation by dispossession, this paper analyses the expansion of agrarian capital in argentina. Dispossession and exploitation israels policy in the jordan valley and northern dead sea 7 the present government, headed by binyamin netanyahu, continues this policy, opposing any withdrawal from the jordan valley. Pdf uneven development and accumulation by dispossession in.
From primitive accumulation to regimes of dispossession six theses on indias land question michael levien existing theoretical perspectives, whether marxs primitive accumulation or harveys accumulation by dispossession, are not adequate for understanding the political economy of land dispossession under capitalismin india or elsewhere. Accumulation by dispossession and the informal economy struggles over knowledge, being and waste at a soweto garbage dump melanie samson environment and planning d. Apr 25, 2019 the process has been described as dispossession by confusion, an uncertain process of dispossession shaped by material and discursive inequalities across indias institutional landscape oskarsson, 20. But, on the other hand, the very nature of these events and the threats they posed economically, politically, and militarily to global security made some sort of indepth analysis imperative. Act to curb the activities of the property grabbers. Umbc college of arts, humanities, and social sciences.
We agree with harvey about the ongoing importance of primitive accumulation, and therefore we have adopted the term accumulation by dispossession. Pdf this paper applies harveys concepts of uneven development and accumulation by dispossession to nature conservation, comparatively. Most notably,david harvey 2003, 144 has introduced the phrase accumulation by dispossession as a substitute for marxs term in order to emphasize the contemporary relevance of the process. Accumulation by dispossession in developing countries. Transformative cities in the new global order, new delhi, sage publications, 2010, 268 pp. Accumulation by dispossession is a concept presented by the marxist geographer david harvey. This article takes the reality television franchise 60 days in as a. David harvey accumulation by dispossession pdf file.
David harveys framework of accumulation by dispossession provides a starting point. For some, the simple occurrence of dispossession seems to be. It defines neoliberal capitalist policies that result in a centralization of wealth printexport. New international trade agreements favorable to globalized capital wto, nafta, etc. Faced with a crisis of profitabilitya crisis in its ability to generate profit through the exploitation of laborcapital. To make sense of turkeys experience, we turn our attention to what we call the castilianspanish road, and what lenin called the. Maehkaenahmenaehsaeh turtle island has sustained people and other living things from time immemorial. From marxs theory of primitive accumulation to harveys theory of accumulation by dispossession as is widely known, according to karl marx 1977, 875, primitive or original accumulation is the historical process of divorcing the producer from the means of production and subsistence and creates the two basic classes of capitalist.
While accumulation by dispossession has always been a feature of capitalism, harvey argues, it became increasingly significant during the long period of economic crisis beginning in the 1970s that continues to this day. Accumulation by dispossession research papers academia. The concept of accumulation by dispossession is an expansion of karl marxs original theory of capital accumulation, which is typically based on the assumption of a freely functioning competitive markets with institutional arrangements of private property, juridical individualism, freedom of contract and. However, many scholars have argued that the idea of a generic global land grab conceals a.
Accumulation by dispossession is a concept presented by the marxist geographer david harvey, which defines the neoliberal capitalist policies in many western nations, from the 1970s and to the. This phenomenon, harvey argues, is a response by capital to a crisis of overaccumulationa condition where surpluses of capital. Accumulation by dispossession and the informal economy. Chapter 4 summarises the empirical evidence and analyses three casestudies of land transactions to assess which conception of growth. Accumulation by dispossession from primitive accumulation to accumulation by dispossession. A history of dispossession those who genuinely seek durable institutions of property and ownership cannot simply invoke the political transition, like a sorcerers trick, to erase the illegitimate origins of what they now seek seamlessly to dignify as property. There seems to be a fairly obvious bias towards the forms of exclusion that can. Accumulation by dispossession of land of indigenous people. For example, the debate over finance capital and foreclosure, the dispossession of rights homelessness. Land transactions in rural india university of oxford. Accumulation, dispossession and urban inequality in pakistan, faculty presentation series, department of. Summary the question as to who and what is responsible for african underdevelopment can be answered at two levels. Primitive accumulation, enclavity, rural marginalisation.
In the regions picture of an antifracking protest in ouargla, february 2015. Data colonialism through accumulation by dispossession. Special economic zones and accumulation by dispossession in india. According to david harvey, accumulation by dispossession abd has become the dominant form of accumulation under the mantra of neoliberalism backed by the state policies, whether in developed or in developing economies. The concept of accumulation by dispossession is a valuable framework for understanding these processes. The banks push for dispossession is rooted in the emergence of post. Keywords data colonialism, big data, everyday life, accumulation by dispossession, commodification, critical data studies references andrejevic, m 2002 the work of being watched. It does so by focusing on canada as a leader in the. Neoliberalist criticism on accumulation by dispossession it is nevertheless important to mention that harveys approach has been criticized from neoliberalist authors. The impacts of discretionary arrests in new york city article pdf available in race and justice november 2017 with 83 reads how we measure reads.
We argue that the asymmetry of this data capture process is a means of capitalist accumulation by dispossession that colonizes and commodifies everyday life in ways previously impossible. Firstly, the answer is that the operation of the imperialist system bears major responsibility for african economic retardation by draining. Complex and interconnected systems of life make up its forests, rivers, lakes, prairies, and tundra. Pdf accumulation by dispossession and socioenvironmental. Create a book download as pdf printable versionthe new imperialism. Major real estate developers, engineering and construction firms, and corporate brands need favelas to be pacified in order for the valorization of commodified assets to occur.
The main focus of this paper, however, is on the effects of accumulation by dispossession on development. Law, extralegality, and illegality commingle in urban slums to produce spaces and subjects at the. A westerntype property regime is indeed central in the functioning of capitalism itself by standardising the economic system, by fixing the economic potential of resources in order. Chapter 3 identifies how these growth theories might appear in indian land transactions. Despite their theoretical and political potential, recent debates on enclosure. In this paper i argue that various forms of accumulation by dispossession and displacement, associated with policies of neoliberalization, exacerbate human vulnerabilities and increasingly constitute a major risk to security both directly and indirectly through contributing to growing inequalities. The dispossession of africas wealth by patrick bond1 slides are available here.
They do not claim that this is an exhaustive list of all the specific forms of exclusion that can be found in the countries of southeast asia. Women in honduras and guatemala in the global scramble for land by aisling walsh trocaire abstract this paper focuses on two cases from the polochic valley, guatemala and the bajo aguan valley, honduras where hundreds of families have been forcefully evicted from, or coerced. Environmental issues capital formation analysis illegal dumping refuse and refuse disposal methods underground economy waste management. The corporate food regime is presented here as a vector of the project of global development. Documents obtained through the right to information act also show that the. Economist fine argues that it seems as if an unduly diverse set of factors is being collected under the umbrella of accumulation by dispossession.
Accumulation by dispossession and the informal economystruggles over knowledge, being and waste at a soweto garbage dump. As such, it expresses not only the social and ecological contradictions of capitalism, but also the worldhistorical conjuncture in which the deployment of price and credit relations are key mechanisms of accumulation through dispossession. Opening up of the global south to foreign direct investment. Accumulation of reserves of marginalized and underused agricultural land. This early mining growth primarily occurred towards the east, in and around dhanbad but. Such policies are visible in many western nations from the 1970s and to the present day.
1119 1350 1117 301 557 470 1262 113 202 323 1411 1215 1355 166 250 1159 1337 874 257 1276 149 1339 188 534 1207 177 1169 1020 1469 125 214